🔑

WYLT Rankings · 2026

Best neighborhoods for first-time buyers
in New York

Ranked by value — neighborhoods with lower home prices that still deliver a strong WYLT verdict.

✓ Affordable price
✓ Good verdict
✓ Walkability
25 neighborhoods ranked
👨‍👩‍👧‍👦 Families💻 Remote Workers🌅 Retirees🔑 First-Time Buyers

#1 Pick for First-Time Buyers in New York

Schenectady, Schenectady — Good for now

#1

Schenectady

Good for now

Schenectady, NY

Price

$140K

Schools

7.3/10

Walk

89/100

View report →
#2

Kew Gardens

Good for now

Kew Gardens, NY

Price

$374K

Schools

7.4/10

Walk

90/100

View report →
#3

Bronx

Think twice

Bronx, NY

Price

$243K

Schools

7.3/10

Walk

73/100

View report →
#4

Jackson Heights

Good for now

Jackson Heights, NY

Price

$429K

Schools

7.3/10

Walk

94/100

View report →
#5

New York City

Think twice

New York City, NY

Price

$535K

Schools

8.5/10

Walk

98/100

View report →
#6

Syracuse

Think twice

Syracuse, NY

Price

$82K

Schools

6.7/10

Walk

47/100

View report →
#7

Bronx

Think twice

Bronx, NY

Price

$476K

Schools

7.1/10

Walk

92/100

View report →
#8

Forest Hills

Good for now

Forest Hills, NY

Price

$559K

Schools

7.4/10

Walk

98/100

View report →
#9

Rego Park

Settle here

Rego Park, NY

Price

$481K

Schools

7.4/10

Walk

88/100

View report →
#10

Bronx

Good for now

Bronx, NY

Price

$399K

Schools

7.2/10

Walk

73/100

View report →
#11

Hempstead

Think twice

Hempstead, NY

Price

$425K

Schools

7.3/10

Walk

74/100

View report →
#12

Albany

Think twice

Albany, NY

0

Schools

7.2/10

Walk

96/100

View report →
#13

Niagara Falls

Think twice

Niagara Falls, NY

Price

$69K

Schools

7.3/10

Walk

23/100

View report →
#14

White Plains

Good for now

White Plains, NY

Price

$367K

Schools

7.4/10

Walk

58/100

View report →
#15

Flushing

Good for now

Flushing, NY

Price

$513K

Schools

7.3/10

Walk

77/100

View report →
#16

Bronx

Think twice

Bronx, NY

Price

$371K

Schools

7/10

Walk

55/100

View report →
#17

Buffalo

Think twice

Buffalo, NY

Price

$486K

Schools

7.2/10

Walk

57/100

View report →
#18

Troy

Good for now

Troy, NY

Price

$212K

Schools

7.4/10

Walk

20/100

View report →
#19

Binghamton

Think twice

Binghamton, NY

Price

$139K

Schools

6.6/10

Walk

11/100

View report →
#20

Mount Vernon

Think twice

Mount Vernon, NY

Price

$453K

Schools

7.1/10

Walk

44/100

View report →
#21

Utica

Think twice

Utica, NY

Price

$129K

Schools

6.2/10

Walk

4/100

View report →
#22

Ithaca

Good for now

Ithaca, NY

Price

$321K

Schools

7.7/10

View report →
#23

Howard Beach

Think twice

Howard Beach, NY

Price

$596K

Schools

7.3/10

Walk

37/100

View report →
#24

Yonkers

Think twice

Yonkers, NY

Price

$400K

Schools

7.1/10

Walk

8/100

View report →
#25

New Rochelle

Think twice

New Rochelle, NY

Price

$525K

Schools

7.2/10

Walk

11/100

View report →
← All neighborhoods in New YorkBrowse all states →