WYLT Neighborhood Rankings · 2026
Best Neighborhoods
in South Dakota
Ranked by safety, schools, walkability, and value. Every verdict is based on real data — no sponsored rankings, no fluff.
#1 Pick in South Dakota
Watertown, Watertown is the top-rated neighborhood in South Dakota — rated "Good for now."
Top 20 Neighborhoods in South Dakota
Watertown
Good for nowWatertown, SD
Price
$213K
Walk
7/100
Schools
7.8/10
Sturgis
Good for nowSturgis, SD
Price
$226K
Schools
8.2/10
Harrisburg
Good for nowHarrisburg, SD
Price
$271K
Schools
6.9/10
Belle Fourche
Good for nowBelle Fourche, SD
Price
$195K
Schools
6.3/10
Yankton
Good for nowYankton, SD
Price
$199K
Walk
18/100
Schools
6.3/10
Tea
Good for nowTea, SD
Price
$287K
Schools
6.9/10
Mitchell
Good for nowMitchell, SD
Price
$180K
Schools
6.8/10
Madison
Good for nowMadison, SD
Price
$173K
Schools
3.9/10
Sioux Falls
Good for nowSioux Falls, SD
Price
$164K
Walk
18/100
Schools
6.9/10
Aberdeen
Think twiceAberdeen, SD
Price
$204K
Walk
33/100
Schools
7.8/10
Dell Rapids
Good for nowDell Rapids, SD
Price
$273K
Walk
11/100
Schools
3.9/10
Rapid City
Good for nowRapid City, SD
Price
$207K
Schools
7.2/10
Brookings
Think twiceBrookings, SD
Price
$229K
Walk
44/100
Schools
5.7/10
Pierre
Think twicePierre, SD
Price
$219K
Walk
6/100
Schools
6.9/10
Spearfish
Think twiceSpearfish, SD
Price
$289K
Walk
20/100
Schools
4.7/10
Hot Springs
Think twiceHot Springs, SD
Price
$184K
Walk
20/100
Schools
4.7/10
Vermillion
Think twiceVermillion, SD
Price
$213K
Schools
5.9/10
Box Elder
Think twiceBox Elder, SD
Price
$270K
Schools
6/10
Huron
Think twiceHuron, SD
Price
$153K
Walk
15/100
Schools
6.5/10
Brandon
Think twiceBrandon, SD
Price
$309K
Schools
6.2/10
How we rank neighborhoods in South Dakota
Every neighborhood on this list was evaluated using real data across four dimensions: safety (violent and property crime risk), schools (rating out of 10), walkability (Walk Score out of 100), and home prices relative to the South Dakota average. Our scoring model weighs each factor equally and assigns one of four plain-English verdicts — from "Settle here" (our highest rating) to "Hard pass" — so you know exactly where each place stands without having to decode letter grades.
Rankings are updated as new reports are generated. All data is sourced from public records, national databases, and our AI-assisted analysis. Click any neighborhood to read its full report.