Box Elder, Box Elder SD — neighborhood review

Box Elder, SD

Box Elder · Pennington County · SD 57719

Updated August 2, 2026 · Would You Live There?

Think twice

Verdict

$317K

Median Price

28/100

Walk Score

6.4/10

Schools

35 min

to Rapid City

Score Breakdown

CAffordability
63/100
BSafety
78/100
CSchools
64/100
B-Quietness
70/100
B-Commute
70/100
FWalkability
28/100
WYLT Score62/100

Our Take

Box Elder offers affordable homes and a tight‑knit small‑town vibe, but its lack of walkability, limited amenities, and recent reports of dog attacks make it a risky choice for families who want convenient access to services or a low‑risk environment.

B.

Visiting Box Elder before you decide?

Scout the neighborhood in person — find hotels near Box Elder.

Find hotels on Booking.com →

Community Poll

Would you move to Box Elder?

Explore this neighborhood

Ready to make the move?

Compare local moving labor and truck rental help, then book movers for your move to Box Elder.

Get moving quotes on HireAHelper →

Map

Loading map…

The Good

  • ✓Median home price ($270k) is below the national average and well matched to median income ($72k).
  • ✓Low flood risk and generally low violent crime for a small town.
  • ✓Good schools with several elementary options and a decent high school.
  • ✓Community feels tight‑knit and generally friendly to families.

Real Talk

  • !Almost all errands require a car – the town’s walk score is 0.
  • !Limited dining, nightlife, and cultural options; most entertainment is a drive away.
  • !Recent media coverage of pit‑bull attacks has raised concerns about dog safety and community safety awareness.
  • !Job opportunities are sparse; many residents commute to nearby larger cities for work.
  • $Higher auto costs due to car‑dependent lifestyle.
  • $Utility bills can be higher in rural areas (heat, water).
  • $Homeowners’ insurance may be pricier if you own a dog or live in a higher‑risk area.

Best For

Families looking for affordable rural livingPeople who prefer a close‑knit communityIndividuals willing to drive for amenitiesThose who are comfortable with car dependence

Risk Snapshot

Flood riskLow
Violent crimeLow
Property crimeModerate
Air qualityGood
Price volatilityLow

Crime & Safety

Box Elder, SD

B

Safety grade

Safety score78 / 100
High riskVery safe
⚠️Violent Crime
Low
1.6incidents / 1,000 residents / yr
0Natl avg (3.7)11+

57% safer than the national average

🔒Property Crime
Moderate
19.8incidents / 1,000 residents / yr
0Natl avg (19.5)59+

2% higher than the national average

Verify with real-time data

City-Data stats →

From Residents

🏘

Loading…

📬

Stay in the loop on Box Elder

Get one email when this report refreshes (~every 90 days). No spam.

One email per update · unsubscribe any time

Know someone considering this area? Send them this report.

wouldyoulivethere.com/report/box-elder-sd-57719