Staten Island, Staten Island NY — neighborhood review

Staten Island, NY

Staten Island · NY 10304

Updated August 4, 2026 · Would You Live There?

Good for now

Verdict

$679K

Median Price

73/100

Walk Score

8.5/10

Schools

33 min

to Midtown Manhattan, NY

Score Breakdown

FAffordability
15/100
D+Safety
55/100
B+Schools
85/100
B-Quietness
70/100
B-Commute
70/100
BWalkability
73/100
WYLT Score61/100

Our Take

Staten Island 10304 offers a solid 33‑minute commute to Midtown Manhattan and decent schools, but it’s very car‑dependent and home prices are high relative to the median income. It’s quiet and family‑friendly with low flood risk, yet limited transit, nightlife and a few hidden costs make it a good choice for those who value space and commute, not for those looking for a walkable, vibrant urban vibe.

B.

Visiting Staten Island before you decide?

Scout the neighborhood in person — find hotels near Staten Island.

Find hotels on Booking.com →

Community Poll

Would you move to Staten Island?

Explore this neighborhood

Ready to make the move?

Compare local moving labor and truck rental help, then book movers for your move to Staten Island.

Get moving quotes on HireAHelper →

Map

Loading map…

The Good

  • ✓33‑minute commute to Midtown Manhattan
  • ✓Low flood risk (Zone X)
  • ✓Decent public school ratings (average 7.5)
  • ✓Quiet, family‑friendly neighborhood with parks

Real Talk

  • !Housing prices (~$653k) are high compared to median income (~$69k)
  • !Public transit options are limited; the area is very car‑dependent
  • !Nightlife and dining options are sparse, mainly suburban‑style
  • !Traffic can be heavy during peak hours
  • $High property taxes typical of New York City boroughs
  • $Insurance costs may be above average due to infrastructure and port proximity
  • $Parking fees or tolls for commuters to Manhattan add extra expense

Best For

FamiliesCommutersRetireesPet owners

Risk Snapshot

Flood riskLow
Violent crimeModerate
Property crimeModerate
Air qualityModerate
Price volatilityModerate

Crime & Safety

Staten Island, NY

D+

Safety grade

Safety score55 / 100
High riskVery safe
⚠️Violent Crime
Moderate
3.9incidents / 1,000 residents / yr
0Natl avg (3.7)11+

5% higher than the national average

🔒Property Crime
Moderate
19.8incidents / 1,000 residents / yr
0Natl avg (19.5)59+

2% higher than the national average

Verify with real-time data

City-Data stats →

From Residents

🏘

Loading…

📬

Stay in the loop on Staten Island

Get one email when this report refreshes (~every 90 days). No spam.

One email per update · unsubscribe any time

Know someone considering this area? Send them this report.

wouldyoulivethere.com/report/staten-island-ny-10304