What are the hidden costs of living in Staten Island?

High property taxes typical of New York City boroughs Insurance costs may be above average due to infrastructure and port proximity Parking fees or tolls for commuters to Manhattan add extra expense

Who is Staten Island best for?

Staten Island is best for: Families, Commuters, Retirees, Pet owners.

What is the median home price in Staten Island?

The median home price in Staten Island is approximately $653,100.

Is Staten Island walkable?

Staten Island has a Walk Score of 39 out of 100. Most errands require a car.

Staten Island, NY

Updated April 29, 2026 · Would You Live There? · Covers: Staten Island, New York

Good for now

Verdict

$653K

Median Price

39/100

Walk Score

7.5/10

Schools

33 min

to Midtown Manhattan, NY

Score Breakdown

FAffordability

15/100

FWalkability

39/100

D+Safety

55/100

B-Commute

70/100

B-Quietness

70/100

BSchools

75/100

WYLT Score54/100

Our Take

Staten Island 10304 offers a solid 33‑minute commute to Midtown Manhattan and decent schools, but it’s very car‑dependent and home prices are high relative to the median income. It’s quiet and family‑friendly with low flood risk, yet limited transit, nightlife and a few hidden costs make it a good choice for those who value space and commute, not for those looking for a walkable, vibrant urban vibe.

Map

Loading map…

The Good

✓33‑minute commute to Midtown Manhattan
✓Low flood risk (Zone X)
✓Decent public school ratings (average 7.5)
✓Quiet, family‑friendly neighborhood with parks

Real Talk

!Housing prices (~$653k) are high compared to median income (~$69k)
!Public transit options are limited; the area is very car‑dependent
!Nightlife and dining options are sparse, mainly suburban‑style
!Traffic can be heavy during peak hours
$High property taxes typical of New York City boroughs
$Insurance costs may be above average due to infrastructure and port proximity
$Parking fees or tolls for commuters to Manhattan add extra expense

Best For

FamiliesCommutersRetireesPet owners

Risk Snapshot

Flood riskLow

Violent crimeModerate

Property crimeModerate

Air qualityModerate

Price volatilityModerate

Crime & Safety

Staten Island, NY

D+

Safety grade

Safety score55 / 100

High riskVery safe

⚠️Violent Crime

Moderate

3.9incidents / 1,000 residents / yr

0Natl avg (3.7)11+

5% higher than the national average

🔒Property Crime

Moderate

19.8incidents / 1,000 residents / yr

0Natl avg (19.5)59+

2% higher than the national average

Verify with real-time data

AreaVibes crime →City-Data stats →NeighborhoodScout →

Rates are estimated from neighborhood characteristics using national FBI baselines. Actual figures vary by block — always verify with local sources before making decisions.

Similar Neighborhoods

Think twice

Staten Island

Staten Island, NY

$642K · 7.4/10 schools

Think twice

Howard Beach

Howard Beach, NY

$596K · 7.3/10 schools

Good for now

Cherrywood

Cherrywood, TX

$623K · 7.4/10 schools

Good for now

Hyde Park

Hyde Park, TX

$627K · 7.4/10 schools

From Residents

🏘

Loading…

Know someone considering this area? Send them this report.

wouldyoulivethere.com/report/staten-island-ny-10304

📬

Stay in the loop on Staten Island

Get one email when this report refreshes (~every 90 days). No spam.