Middletown, NJ
Updated April 30, 2026 · Would You Live There?
Good for now
Verdict
$523K
Median Price
46/100
Walk Score
6.3/10
Schools
75 min
to Midtown Manhattan
Score Breakdown
Our Take
Middletown offers solid income levels and a decent median home price, but it’s a car‑dependent suburb with limited public transit and a modest walk score. It’s quiet and family‑friendly, yet commuting to NYC can be a long, costly ride.
Map
The Good
- ✓Median income $141k beats the median home price of $523k, leaving room for a comfortable mortgage
- ✓Low flood risk (Zone X) gives peace of mind for homeowners
- ✓Several high‑rated schools in the area support families
- ✓Suburban quiet with decent parks and green space
Real Talk
- !Walk score 46 means you’ll need a car for most errands
- !Transit score 10 indicates minimal bus or train options—commuting to NYC can take 75‑90 minutes and cost over $10 a day
- !Some local high schools have ratings as low as 3, so school quality varies
- !Housing supply is limited, so prices can rise quickly and reduce affordability
- $High NJ property taxes add to the cost of ownership
- $Car maintenance, insurance, and parking are inevitable expenses
- $Utility bills can be high in the colder months
Best For
Risk Snapshot
Crime & Safety
Middletown, NJ
Safety grade
5% higher than the national average
2% higher than the national average
Verify with real-time data
Rates are estimated from neighborhood characteristics using national FBI baselines. Actual figures vary by block — always verify with local sources before making decisions.
Similar Neighborhoods
East Austin
East Austin, TX
$570K · 7.3/10 schools
Saint Paul
Saint Paul, MN
$445K · 6.1/10 schools
Dallas
Dallas, TX
$435K · 7.1/10 schools
Miami
Miami, FL
$462K · 6.9/10 schools
From Residents
Loading…
Know someone considering this area? Send them this report.
wouldyoulivethere.com/report/middletown-nj-07748
Stay in the loop on Middletown
Get one email when this report refreshes (~every 90 days). No spam.