Loading neighborhood data…
Brewster, NY
Brewster · NY 10509
Updated October 31, 2026 · Would You Live There?
Good for now
Verdict
$620K
Median Price
…
Walk Score
7/10
Schools
83 min
to Midtown Manhattan, NY
Score Breakdown
DAffordability
45/100
ASafety
92/100
B-Schools
70/100
B+Quietness
80/100
FCommute
35/100
FWalkability
0/100
WYLT Score54/100
Our Take
Brewster offers solid suburban living with a strong median income, good schools, and a low flood risk, but it is very car‑dependent and the commute to Manhattan is long. It’s a decent place for families and commuters who don’t mind limited local amenities.
B.
Visiting Brewster before you decide?
Scout the neighborhood in person — find hotels near Brewster.
Find hotels on Booking.com →Community Poll
Would you move to Brewster?
Explore this neighborhood
Ready to make the move?
Compare local moving labor and truck rental help, then book movers for your move to Brewster.
Get moving quotes on HireAHelper →Map
Loading map…
The Good
- ✓Strong median income and good school ratings
- ✓Low flood risk and moderate property taxes relative to the region
- ✓Convenient Metro‑North station for commuters
- ✓Family‑friendly environment with decent parks and open space
Real Talk
- !Walkability is minimal – most errands require a car
- !Transit is limited to a single train line with few bus connections
- !Commute to Manhattan is long (about 83 minutes)
- !Local dining and nightlife options are sparse
- $Higher property taxes typical of upstate NY
- $Insurance can be higher for larger rural homes
- $Maintenance costs for older single‑family homes
Best For
FamiliesCommutersHomebuyers looking for a quieter lifestylePeople who prefer a single‑family home setting
Risk Snapshot
Flood riskLow
Violent crimeLow
Property crimeLow
Air qualityGood
Price volatilityModerate
Crime & Safety
Brewster, NY
A
Safety grade
Safety score92 / 100
High riskVery safe
⚠️Violent Crime
Low1.6incidents / 1,000 residents / yr
0Natl avg (3.7)11+
57% safer than the national average
🔒Property Crime
Low9.8incidents / 1,000 residents / yr
0Natl avg (19.5)59+
50% safer than the national average
Verify with real-time data
City-Data stats →From Residents
🏘
Loading…
📬
Stay in the loop on Brewster
Get one email when this report refreshes (~every 90 days). No spam.
Know someone considering this area? Send them this report.
wouldyoulivethere.com/report/brewster-ny-10509