Let the numbers do the talking.
Montclair, NJ vs South Orange, NJ
Montclair, NJ vs South Orange, NJ: What the data shows
Montclair, NJ is in Montclair, NJ while South Orange, NJ is in South Orange, NJ — both in the same state. On home prices, Montclair, NJ is the more affordable option at $673,900 median — $95,200 less than South Orange, NJ's $769,100. WYLT rates Montclair, NJ as “Settle here” — an excellent place to put down roots — and South Orange, NJ as “Settle here” — an excellent place to put down roots.
South Orange, NJ has the stronger safety profile of the two. Montclair, NJ has Low violent crime and Moderate property crime. South Orange, NJ has Low violent crime and Low property crime. On environmental risk, Montclair, NJ has Low flood risk and South Orange, NJ has Low flood risk.
For families weighing school quality, South Orange, NJ has the higher school rating — Montclair, NJ rates 7.5/10 and South Orange, NJ rates 8.8/10.
| Category | Montclair, NJ | South Orange, NJ |
|---|---|---|
| Housing | ||
| Verdict | Settle here | Settle here |
| Median Price | $674K ✓ Lower price | $769K |
| Median Rent | $2K ✓ Lower rent | $2K |
| Median Income | $130K | $173K ✓ Higher income |
| Price Volatility | Moderate | Moderate |
| Getting Around | ||
| Walk Score | Car-dependent | Car-dependent |
| Transit Score | Minimal transit | Minimal transit |
| Bike Score | N/A | N/A |
| Commute | 31 min ✓ Shorter commute | 37 min |
| Safety & Environment | ||
| Safety Grade | B | A ✓ Safer |
| Violent Crime | Low | Low |
| Property Crime | Moderate | Low ✓ Lower risk |
| Flood Risk | Low | Low |
| Air Quality | Good | Good |
| Community | ||
| Schools | 7.5/10 | 8.8/10 ✓ Better schools |
| Best for | FamiliesProfessionalsCommuters | FamiliesProfessionalsThose who value excellent schools |
Bottom line
If you prioritize a slightly more affordable option with a similar set of amenities, Montclair may be the better choice, despite its lack of walkability and unclear school rating. However, if you're willing to pay a premium for a potentially more diverse and creative community, South Orange might be worth considering, but be prepared for high costs and uncertainty around key factors. Overall, Montclair is the safer bet for young families and singles due to its established reputation and slightly lower cost of living.
Share this comparison