WYLT Neighborhood Rankings · 2026

Best Neighborhoods
in Idaho

Ranked by safety, schools, walkability, and value. Every verdict is based on real data — no sponsored rankings, no fluff.

21 neighborhoods reviewed
15 "Good for now" picks

#1 Pick in Idaho

Ammon, Ammon is the top-rated neighborhood in Idaho rated "Good for now."

Top 21 Neighborhoods in Idaho

#1

Ammon

Good for now

Ammon, ID

Price

$296K

Walk

13/100

Schools

7.5/10

View report →
#2

Hayden

Good for now

Hayden, ID

Price

$435K

Schools

8.2/10

View report →
#3

Meridian

Good for now

Meridian, ID

Price

$429K

Schools

7.6/10

View report →
#4

Twin Falls

Good for now

Twin Falls, ID

Price

$255K

Walk

27/100

Schools

7.4/10

View report →
#5

Coeur d'Alene

Good for now

Coeur d'Alene, ID

Price

$451K

Walk

43/100

Schools

7.9/10

View report →
#6

Boise

Good for now

Boise, ID

Price

$645K

Walk

9/100

Schools

7.5/10

View report →
#7

Blackfoot

Good for now

Blackfoot, ID

Price

$227K

Walk

43/100

Schools

6.7/10

View report →
#8

Mountain Home

Good for now

Mountain Home, ID

Price

$239K

Walk

14/100

Schools

6.8/10

View report →
#9

Caldwell

Good for now

Caldwell, ID

Price

$256K

Walk

13/100

Schools

6.5/10

View report →
#10

Eagle

Good for now

Eagle, ID

Price

$652K

Schools

7.6/10

View report →
#11

Boise

Good for now

Boise, ID

Price

$322K

Walk

20/100

Schools

7.5/10

View report →
#12

Pocatello

Good for now

Pocatello, ID

Price

$219K

Schools

7.1/10

View report →
#13

Nampa

Good for now

Nampa, ID

Price

$263K

Walk

15/100

Schools

6.3/10

View report →
#14

Idaho Falls

Good for now

Idaho Falls, ID

Price

$273K

Schools

7.9/10

View report →
#15

Lewiston

Good for now

Lewiston, ID

Price

$266K

Schools

7.4/10

View report →
#16

Moscow

Think twice

Moscow, ID

Price

$322K

Walk

12/100

Schools

7.3/10

View report →
#17

Sandpoint

Think twice

Sandpoint, ID

Price

$420K

Walk

3/100

Schools

7.5/10

View report →
#18

Rexburg

Think twice

Rexburg, ID

Price

$331K

Schools

8/10

View report →
#19

Star

Think twice

Star, ID

Price

$471K

Schools

7.6/10

View report →
#20

Post Falls

Think twice

Post Falls, ID

Price

$375K

Schools

7.9/10

View report →
#21

Jerome

Think twice

Jerome, ID

Price

$239K

Schools

6.4/10

View report →

How we rank neighborhoods in Idaho

Every neighborhood on this list was evaluated using real data across four dimensions: safety (violent and property crime risk), schools (rating out of 10), walkability (Walk Score out of 100), and home prices relative to the Idaho average. Our scoring model weighs each factor equally and assigns one of four plain-English verdicts — from "Settle here" (our highest rating) to "Hard pass" — so you know exactly where each place stands without having to decode letter grades.

Rankings are updated as new reports are generated. All data is sourced from public records, national databases, and our AI-assisted analysis. Click any neighborhood to read its full report.